"Nothing Left To Hold On To"
a sermon delivered by
the Reverend Barbara D. Morgan
on Sunday, January 9, 2000
at Community Unitarian Universalist Church
in Daytona Beach, Florida
Before I begin my sermon, I would like to offer you a tiny
cup of lavender potion. Please hold your potion until I direct
you to sip it. We will sip potion four times this morning. The
ingredients are natural yogurt and grape juice mostly.
If you have any food allergies, each potion passer has a list
of all the ingredients, and can give you the list. I ask you
not to sample the potion until the time comes for us all to sample
it together. Some of you may ask, "Why a potion? Why something
thought to be medicinal, magic, or poisonous?" I can think
of several reasons perhaps to turn this sermon into "performance
art." Perhaps to offer those among us who live too much
in our minds a reminder that we have bodies, too. Perhaps, to
be playful. Perhaps because I have fallen under the spell of
Harry Potter, about whom I'll speak in a moment.
This morning I address endings, feeling like "there is
nothing left to hold on to." Endings are the beginnings
of transitions. The best book I know of on transitions is this
one: Transitions, Making Sense of Life's Changes, Strategies
for coping with the difficult, painful, and confusing times in
your life. It was written by William Bridges twenty years
ago. It remains a classic. If you are interested in reading this
book, you may borrow or buy a copy after the service. If you're
buying the book, please put $14 in the basket. If you're borrowing
the book, please put a label from the basket on the cover of
the book.
I speak of endings today because I have resigned as New Congregation
Minister of Community Unitarian Universalist Church. I sent a
letter to each member and friend regularly attending church on
Thursday. If you haven't already read my letter or if the informal
communication channels haven't gotten the news to you yet, I
apologize for the shock of hearing this news from the pulpit.
Perhaps you may even join me in feeling teary. If so, there are
tissues on the stand with the books. You're welcome to use them.
If you're brand new to Community Church, let me give you a
brief synopsis. This congregation began as an idea in 1996. It
became a reality in 1997, when it began offering public worship
and other programs. In December, 1997 I was appointed New Congregation
Minister by the Unitarian Universalist Association, and my appointment
was affirmed by all but one of the members of Community Church
who voted that first Sunday of December, two years ago. My partner,
Patricia, and I moved from Seattle to Daytona Beach in January,
1998. I began my ministry here two years ago on February 1.
So, dear visitors, I speak today of specific transitions
this congregation's and mine. But in reality our experiences
are an example of a process common to us all. As you listen you
will notice that the same stages apply to many transitions you
have experienced or are experiencing in your life.
So, let us speak of endings.
Last month I read the first book in the Harry Potter series,
written by J.K. Rowling. It's called Harry Potter and the
Sorcerer's Stone. I wanted to find out for myself what all
the fuss is about. I found it a delightful, imaginative read.
I have no more concern about children trying to cast magic spells
after reading a Harry Potter book than I do their trying to walk
on water after having read Matthew 14, or Mark or John 6
the Christian Bible passages where Jesus asks his disciples to
walk on water. I am grateful to Harry for popping into my life
right at this point. My hope is that Harry Potter may supply
some gentle humor to this otherwise sad occasion.
Of course, by introducing Harry Potter into this sermon I
have further complicated a sermon which was perhaps already complicated
enough. Let me explain a little bit about Harry briefly.
Harry is an orphan wizard being reluctantly raised by his abusive
aunt and uncle and tormented by his older cousin. Happily for
Harry and his readers we learn in Chapter Four that
Harry is to attend Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry,
a boarding school. If that were the end of it, the book wouldn't
have seventeen chapters and several sequels. At Hogwarts Harry
has challenges that far surpass those of his early childhood,
both in their imaginative character and in their potential for
danger. Therein lies the tale.
As Harry is to discover, as William Bridges defines, and as
I said when I began, every transition begins with an ending.
Bridges writes that there are four aspects to endings: disengagement,
disidentification, disenchantment, and disorientation. He compares
his four "dis-es" with the five-stage grief sequence
Elisabeth Kubler-Ross identified in her terminally ill patients:
denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. One can
begin anywhere and proceed through the rest in any fashion, perhaps
circling back to certain ones several times. However unless one
experiences all of them, one doesn't truly end, and, therefore,
can't truly begin again. So let us take each of Bridges' "dis-es"
and apply them to our present situation.
Disengagement
Disengagement is a frequent theme in stories of the ancient
and modern world. Jesus had his forty-day journey in the wilderness.
Harry Potter leaves his foster home to go to Hogwarts. I am leaving
Community Church. To disengage means to break with a familiar
social matrix. It is the part of an ending where we most experience
loss. What's interesting is that even if these losses were anticipated,
they are still losses to be grieved. Each attachment we have
gives us something, and when we no longer have these attachments
we lose something.
While living with his aunt and uncle, Harry Potter never had
to prove himself. At Hogwarts he was expected to play a sport
while flying on a broomstick, help hatch a dragon, and foil the
evil plot of the sinister Voldemort.
As minister and congregation we have provided for one another.
Our disengagement means that you shall have to prove yourselves
in ways you haven't before, and I shall have to prove myself
in ways I haven't before.
At this time of disengagement I don't know what the future
holds for me. I do know that I shall feel the loss of the certainty
of this ministry to which I've given a large part of my life.
When I have awakened in the morning I have not had to wonder
what I would do with my day. I have never had to wonder whom
or what I served. You provided the flesh and blood answer. You
have been the mirror that has reflected back to me my progress
as a minister.
For me, now all that has changed. And also for you.
The end of our partnership means the end of my involvement
in your lives. In another congregation, shortly after I arrived
to serve as minister I received a telephone call from a long
absent member. His wife was dying of cancer. Would I come to
visit them and help them plan her memorial service. There was
no question for this man whom to call in this instance
his minister even if that minister were someone he had
never met. When the Minister (with a capital "m") leaves,
whom to call is not so obvious.
The end of our partnership leaves a Sunday morning vacuum.
Instead of 20 Sundays a year, the Worship Committee will be responsible
for 52 Sundays a year. Not an easy task, even for a well-organized
and well-staffed committee.
Outer change is often a signal of inner change as well. Disengagement
the disappearance of an old system means that old
ways of knowing ourselves gives way to the new. As long as we
are together, as long as we operate out of the "cue-system"
we have created together to tell us who we are and how we shall
behave, we will not discover alternative ways of knowing ourselves,
alternative identities.
And so disengagement brings the loss of a familiar social
matrix, the grief process with all its stages, the need to prove
ourselves anew, the loss of certainty, the loss of our dependable
relationship, and more work for all of you, especially the Worship
Committee. Let us take our first sip of our potion -- to disengagement
which holds the possibility of a new way of knowing ourselves.
Disidentification
William Bridges calls disidentification the inner side of
the disengagement process. As Harry Potter disengages from his
foster home, he also disidentifies as poor, picked-on, much abused
Harry.
Social identities are important to us. Many of us use nouns
to identify ourselves teacher, student, minister. Some
of us use modifiers divorced, single, married, partnered.
Some of us have what Bridges calls "participial" identities
mine are reading, knitting, writing.
My professional identity has been New Congregation Minister
of Community Unitarian Universalist Church in Daytona Beach,
Florida. As I enter my transition I lose this identity.
For some of you and for some of the world, Community Unitarian
Universalist Church in Daytona Beach, Florida has been identified
as the congregation served by the Reverend Barbara Morgan. As
you enter your transition you lose this identity.
It is for you to discover your new identity, just as I have
to discover my new identity. No one can do it for us. In the
meantime we suffer the discomfort of social limbo a church
without a minister! a minister without a church! Fortunately
for you, in Unitarian Universalist circles it is not unusual
for a congregation not to have a minister. In the Florida district,
nearly 60% of our congregations are served by ministers. Of these,
three quarters have full-time professional leadership and the
remainder are served by their ministers on a part-time basis.
More than 40% of all congregations in the UUA Florida district
do not have professional religious leadership. So you will be
in good company. And remember these figures. When your Baptist
or Lutheran or Catholic neighbor asks you why this congregation
calls itself a church when it has no minister, say to them, "It's
not unusual in our religion for congregations to be lay-lead.
In fact close to half of all the Unitarian Universalist congregations
in Florida have no ministers."
A minister without a pulpit or a congregation is another matter.
Hard as it has been to acclimate myself to being a resident of
Daytona Beach, it has been much easier to think of myself as
your minister. I grieve the loss of my identity as your minister
at the same time that I look forward to many exciting and new
possibilities.
As William Bridges says, "[I]t is important to remember
the significance of disidentification and the need to loosen
the bonds of who we think we are so that we can go through a
transition toward a new identity." Like the sign on the
saloon out west says, "I ain't what I ought to be, and I
ain't what I'm gonna to be. But I ain't what I was!" It's
time for a second sip to Disidentification!
Disenchantment
Remember when you discovered there is no Santa Claus? Or that
your parents sometimes do things they tell you not to do? Or
when you discovered that your best friend, or your spouse, or
your lover was not who you thought they were? That's disenchantment.
As unsure as Harry Potter was about his ability to succeed
at Hogwarts or even to find Hogwarts he was definitely
disenchanted with his foster family! Who wouldn't be willing
to trade a flying broomstick for a closet under the stairs!
Some Community Church members have been disenchanted for some
time. Several members have resigned over the last two years
four of them in the last month. When Bill and Margaret Bailey
resigned, we lost our oldest member Bill Bailey. When Joe
and Mary Claire Lennartz left, taking their children with them,
we lost our youngest child Connor Lennartz.
However simple and self-evident the aspect of disenchantment
seems, it is more complicated than it looks on the surface. William
Bridges puts it this way:
The lesson of disenchantment begins with the discovery that
in order to change really to change, and not just to switch
positions you must realize that some significant part of
your old reality was in your head, not out there. The flawless
parent, the noble leader, the perfect wife, the utterly trustworthy
friend are an inner cast of characters looking for actors
to play the parts.
You were looking for the perfect church, and you found Community
Church. So you called Community Church "perfect". In
truth, Community Church never was, is not now, and never will
be perfect.
You were looking for a wise minister, and you chose me. So
you called me "wise." In truth, I never was, am not
now, and never will be constantly wise. I may have my wise moments,
but I also have my inept, foolish, and awkward moments as well.
My disenchantment focuses on the notion that all conflicts
can be resolved. I forget that attempts to resolve conflicts
can bring irreparable damage. It is with a true sense of disenchantment
a knowing that my staying could inflict more destruction
than can be repaired that I resign as your minister.
Let us "look below the surface of what has been thought
to be so." To Disenchantment!
Disorientation
We live in four dimensions we live in time and in space.
At a time of ending we become disoriented both in time and in
space. Bridges describes this aspect of ending as feeling like
"shipwrecked sailors on some existential atoll." We
don't know where we are and we don't know if we're ever going
to go somewhere ever again.
For Harry Potter, finding Platform Nine and Three-quarters,
said by all responsible people not to exist at all, became a
real test. To suddenly be presented with all sorts of things
he wanted to learn collapsed what used to seem like endless days
to him into minutes.
When I move out of my office, you will have an empty room,
a clear indicator that you have no minister. As critically short
as your storage capacity is, I urge you not to turn what was
once a closet back into a closet again. Let the emptiness of
the space speak to you, inform you, help you fathom the depths
of this ending.
For me, Suite F at 1124 Beville Road will become off limits,
rather than a place where I do my ministry. No longer will I
answer the phone with a 26-syllable tongue twister. No more will
I go through the familiar motions of tilting back my chair as
I talk with you, either in person or on the phone or as
I read or think. I will never again explain to people that I
work west of Office Depot, north of WalMart, and east of Shurgard,
at the north end of the Nova Village parking lot, behind the
Centerfold Lounge. I'll miss shocking people by alerting them
to the reality that a church can survive and thrive within a
long stone's throw of what some think of as a sinful place!
Our sense of time will be disoriented, too. We have no future
together. We may each even wonder if we have a future separately.
It's not for sure that I will continue in parish ministry. It's
not for sure that this congregation will survive such a rocky
start. Yet we each have gifts gifts that will once again
point to a future. But for us, this day, time has stood still,
and we face emptiness. Bridges says,
The problem is not that we don't want to give up a job or
a relationship, or that we can't let go of our identity or our
reality; the problem is that before we can find a new something,
we must deal with a time of nothing. And that prospect awakens
old fears and all the old fantasies about death and abandonment.
A little later, when he describes the middle phase of a transition,
called "the neutral zone," Bridges quotes Leo Tolstoy.
It is from this passage that I have chosen the title of this
sermon. "'I felt,' [Tolstoy] wrote, 'that something had
broken within me on which my life had always rested, that I had
nothing left to hold on to"
Your life and mine has not always rested on our relationship,
yet our relationship has been a big part of my life and for some
of you, yours too. Now that relationship is over.
Let us take our final drink to Disorientation, that
important feeling that reminds us we must first have nothing
before we can have something new. To Disorientation!
Conclusion
If you have received a letter from me, I urge you to read
it. It includes some important information you'll need in this
transition. If you never received a copy or have misplaced your
copy, there are extras at the front desk.
This sermon is the first of three sermons in a series. Next
week I will talk about the Neutral Zone, and in my final sermon
on January 30 I will speak of Beginnings. I will preach in DeLand
on January 23. On February 6 and 13 I will visit the Church School.
Effective February 14, Valentine's Day, I will no longer serve
you as your Minister.
As we end this morning's exploration of Endings, I want to
say thank you. You have taught me much, not the least of which
is that for your church and my ministry to be saved, our relationship
must die. It takes not just courage, but love to bring an end
to our union. Love is powerful. To paraphrase J. K. Rowling's
words, from the first Harry Potter book, to have been loved so
deeply, even though the person or persons who loved us are gone,
will give us some protection forever. It is in our very skins.
|